Talk: Parabolic solar reflectors

Latest revision as of 03:29, 18 January 2012

Photo not from Africa, but from the Caribbean[]

This text on the page needs to be changed or a different photo needs to be uploaded. The photo was taken either in Haiti or Jamaica:

"The parabolic cookers areImage:Being used in Africa as well, and the photo below confirms it further."

I removed the photo for now. Tom Sponheim 04:09, 27 January 2007 (UTC)

New item[]

I would like to write a link in "the parabolic reflector" to Atouts Soleil organization : http://tablesol.free.fr.

I would also like to add some lines about the asymetrical reflector of my solar cooker.

Thank you. Best wishes.

Xavier Devos email : tablesol@yahoo.fr Template:Unsigned

Anyone may edit the articles. Someone may undo your edits if s/he disagrees with the content, however. Nothing is lost, however. A page history of all edits to a page is saved. Please see Solar Cooking Archive Wiki tips for more. Walter Siegmund (talk) 17:42, 21 September 2007 (UTC)

quick notes[]

I've added a "Quick Notes" section on the main page.

DowenWilliams 14:28, September 4, 2010 (UTC) David Williams

How should this article develop?[]

In the last year or so, i.e. 2011, I've done a lot of edits to this page. If you compare it with the Wikipedia "Solar cooker" page, which I have also been editing, you'll see a lot of similarities.

However, there are also large differences. This article is much longer than the Wikipedia one. That's because this page started off, in the early 1980s, as a "compendium" of solar cookers, written by Ashok Kundapur. He wrote a set of descriptions of a whole lot of solar cookers that then existed. How valuable these descriptions are now, some 30 years later, is a matter for debate. He did not include much in the way of theoretical background. Brian White and I have put some theory into the article more recently.

I have not deleted any of Ashok's material (apart from a few trivial edits), but I do feel that, in the interest of conciseness, some of it should go.

What do other people think?

DOwenWilliams 03:29, January 18, 2012 (UTC)

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-== Paraboloid With Coincident Focus and Centre of Mass ==
-Paraboloidal reflectors used as solar concentrators have to turn at 15 degrees per hour to follow the sun's motion in the sky. Ideally, the focal point, where the cooking pot or other energy collector is located, should not move. This means that the rotation axis must pass through the focus. If the rotation is driven by a low-power machine such as a clock, only a small torque is available. In order to rotate the reflector with this small torque, its centre of mass should be on the rotation axis. These two requirements can be simultaneously met if the paraboloid is such that its centre of mass and focal point coincide.
-If the paraboloid is axially symmetrical and is made of material of uniform thickness, this coincidence occurs if the depth of the reflector, measured along the axis of the paraboloid from its vertex to the plane of its rim, is 1.8478 times its focal length. The radius of the rim is 2.7187 times the focal length. (The closeness of this number to "e", the base of natural logarithms, is just a chance coincidence, but can be a useful mnemonic.) The angular radius of the rim, seen from the focus, is 72.68 degrees.
-If the cooking pot is held at the end of a fixed arm that enters the reflector along the line of the paraboloidal axis at noon, the rim of the reflector, which is rotating at 15 degrees per hour, will not strike the arm for more than four hours before and after noon. The device can therefore be used from before 8 a.m. until after 4 p.m. without any need for re-adjustment. Usually, this includes the whole part of the day when the sun is high enough in the sky for solar cooking to be practicable.<br />
-Further information can be found in the "Focus-Balanced Paraboloidal Reflector" page of this wiki
-[[User:DowenWilliams|DowenWilliams]] 22:24, May 25, 2010 (UTC) David Williams
 == Photo not from Africa, but from the Caribbean ==
@@ Line 40: / Line 22: @@
 :Anyone may edit the articles. Someone may undo your edits if s/he disagrees with the content, however. Nothing is lost, however. A page history of all edits to a page is saved. Please see [[Solar Cooking Archive Wiki tips]] for more. [[User:Wsiegmund|Walter Siegmund]] [[User_talk:Wsiegmund|(talk)]] 17:42, 21 September 2007 (UTC)
+== quick notes ==
+I've added a "Quick Notes" section on the main page.
+[[User:DowenWilliams|DowenWilliams]] 14:28, September 4, 2010 (UTC) David Williams
+== How should this article develop? ==
+In the last year or so, i.e. 2011, I've done a lot of edits to this page. If you compare it with the Wikipedia "Solar cooker" page, which I have also been editing, you'll see a lot of similarities.
+However, there are also large differences. This article is much longer than the Wikipedia one. That's because this page started off, in the early 1980s, as a "compendium" of solar cookers, written by Ashok Kundapur. He wrote a set of descriptions of a whole lot of solar cookers that then existed. How valuable these descriptions are now, some 30 years later, is a matter for debate. He did not include much in the way of theoretical background. Brian White and I have put some theory into the article more recently.
+I have not deleted any of Ashok's material (apart from a few trivial edits), but I do feel that, in the interest of conciseness, some of it should go.
+What do other people think?
+[[User:DOwenWilliams|DOwenWilliams]] 03:29, January 18, 2012 (UTC)